Giving Bad News: What to Say to Unsuccessful Job Applicants

Chris Apps • 15 February 2024

Get Straight to the Point & Don't Sugar Coat It

What do you say to an unsuccessful job applicant? In terms of brand awareness, reputation and just doing the right thing, it is prudent to give some feedback to unsuccessful candidates. However, at least anecdotally, many candidates never receive any feedback and just wait and wonder and then eventually just assume they missed out on the job. This person may share this experience with their friends and on the socials, doing you reputational damage.


Some people are very good at giving unsuccessful candidate the bad news; however, I think it is safe to assume that many people find it a real challenge.


My advice is to “rip the band-aid off” so to speak, and say:


“I have some news that might disappoint you”. 

OR

“I’m sorry to let you know that you’ve been unsuccessful”.


Don’t talk about anything else upfront or do the dreaded "
sandwich" approach of a compliment, then the real purpose of the call, and then something positive. Just say, “Hi Chris, this is Chris from Fermion and I have some news that might disappoint you


This puts the person’s mind at ease as they know where they stand, which then allows you to give them some feedback and the confidence to do it again in the future.  


Feel free to like, comment on or share this article. 

About the Author:

Christopher Apps is an Organisational Psychologist and the owner of Fermion. He stays updated on the latest psychology research and shares evidence-based insights.

 

The focus of Fermion is "Psychometric Testing for Recruitment" and "Recruitment to Retention: How to select good staff and keep them". If you would like to learn how to select good staff and keep them, please feel free to contact us at Fermion.


“Learn from the mistakes of others. You can’t live long enough to make them all yourself.”

Eleanor Roosevelt.

Recent Posts

A graphic showing the four elements of EQ
by Chris Apps 27 July 2026
Technical skill is not enough when a role involves people, pressure and judgement. Emotional intelligence can help employers reduce poor hiring decisions.
A test item from an IQ test
by Chris Apps 21 July 2026
A strong CV and interview do not always show whether a candidate can learn quickly, handle complexity and meet the real demands of the role.
Business people looking over accounts
by Chris Apps 14 July 2026
A mishire can cost far more than salary. Better recruitment protects profit, reduces wasted time and builds stronger teams that last and perform well.
A graphic depicting a job candidate between a CV and test
by Chris Apps 10 July 2026
Traditional recruitment rewards confidence and polish. A modern selection process uses stronger evidence to identify who is genuinely most likely to succeed.
A business meeting with one man point his finger in an aggressive manner towards a colleague
by Chris Apps 2 July 2026
Most role failures are not about technical skills alone. Learn how personality, judgement and cognitive fit shape better hiring decisions over time and prevent pain.
A graphic of a bulls eye with a resume attached to an arrow
by Chris Apps 23 June 2026
Candidates can use AI to appear ideal, but presentation is not proof. Discover how a convergence of evidence can reduce the risk of a costly mishire.
Business meeting in a modern conference room, with silhouetted people around a long table at sunset.
by Chris Apps 26 May 2026
Poor hiring decisions do more than create mishires. Without a clear process, they can damage trust, invite claims of bias and expose the business.
Notebook page reading “Role Expectations” with a pen on a wooden desk
by Chris Apps 18 May 2026
Candidates need the truth about the role, the culture and the manager. Honest recruitment reduces mismatched expectations and costly mishires before they start.
Two people in business attire shaking hands across a white desk with paperwork and a keyboard.
by Chris Apps 12 May 2026
Resumes, interviews and reference checks all contain "noise" and error. Discover how stronger recruitment systems improve hiring accuracy and reduce mishires.
Man at desk with coffee and snacks, balancing a pen between two wire fixtures while looking focused
by Chris Apps 5 May 2026
Difficult employees rarely appear overnight. Discover how recruitment decisions influence behaviour and what you can do early to avoid costly mistakes.
Show More