When Your Gut Feeling Gets Recruitment Wrong
Intuition can be a valuable decision making tool, but recruitment is one situation where slowing down can produce better results.
We have all experienced that feeling of knowing something without being entirely sure how we know it. Perhaps we sense that something is wrong, recognise an opportunity or form an immediate impression of someone we have just met.
We often call it intuition or a gut feeling, and although we may struggle to explain the reasoning behind it, that does not necessarily mean it is wrong.
Intuition is generally understood as a quick decision-making that draws on experience, learned patterns and information processed without conscious deliberation. In certain circumstances, particularly when someone has considerable experience in an environment that provides reliable feedback, intuition can be remarkably effective.
An experienced firefighter may recognise the early signs of danger before being able to articulate precisely what is wrong, while a skilled sportsperson can make decisions in fractions of a second that would be impossible through conscious analysis.
There are situations where quick decisions are essential, and intuition can be extremely useful; recruitment, however, is rarely one of them.
Why Recruitment Is Different
When interviewing candidates, we naturally form impressions about their confidence, personality, communication style and whether we think they would fit into the organisation.
These impressions can develop remarkably quickly and may influence how we interpret everything that follows.
A candidate who presents confidently, establishes rapport and communicates well may create a favourable impression, while someone who appears nervous or reserved may be judged less positively, even when those characteristics have little relationship to their ability to perform the job.
Psychologists refer to several processes that help explain this, including the halo effect, confirmation bias and the tendency to place disproportionate weight on information received early in an interaction.
Once we form an initial impression, we may unconsciously look for information that supports it, while paying less attention to evidence that contradicts it.
To manage these issues it is as simple as doing the face-to-face interview last, i.e., screen test and then interview.
Why the Interview Should Come Last
One of the principles I advocate at Fermion is to conduct the face-to-face interview towards the end of the recruitment process, rather than at the beginning.
The reasoning is straightforward.
Before meeting candidates, we should already have gathered as much relevant information as possible through their applications, qualifications, experience, telephone screening and, where appropriate, psychometric testing.
This allows the recruitment panel to develop an evidence-based understanding of each candidate before the potentially powerful influence of personal impressions enters the process.
It also changes the purpose of the interview.
Rather than relying on the interview to discover everything about a candidate, the panel can use it to investigate strengths, explore potential concerns, clarify inconsistencies and test whether the information gathered from other sources tells a consistent story.
A structured interview, using consistent questions and agreed assessment criteria, provides a further safeguard against the influence of first impressions.
And this is where intuition can still play a useful role.
If something about a candidate's responses creates a feeling of uncertainty, that impression need not be ignored. Instead, it can become a reason to ask another question, seek a specific example or examine the evidence more carefully.
The important distinction is that a gut feeling should prompt further investigation rather than become the justification for a recruitment decision.
Better Decisions Through Deliberate Thinking
Recruitment decisions have consequences that can last for years, affecting productivity, workplace relationships, organisational performance and the individuals involved.
Unlike many situations requiring immediate judgement, recruitment generally provides the opportunity to slow down, gather information and consider alternatives before reaching a conclusion.
That opportunity should be used.
Good recruitment is not about eliminating human judgement or pretending that intuition has no value. It is about recognising its limitations and placing it within a process that draws on multiple sources of relevant evidence.
When information from applications, psychometric assessments, structured interviews and reference checks begins to converge, there is a stronger basis for making an informed decision.
Intuition may still contribute to the discussion, but it should not dominate it.
After all, when you have the time and opportunity to make a deliberate, well-informed decision about someone who may work in your organisation for years, why would you rely primarily on a gut feeling?
If you would like to strengthen your recruitment decisions, Fermion provides psychometric testing to complement interviews and other selection methods, helping you develop a more complete understanding of the candidates you are considering.











